Saturday, July 25, 2009

Impound It - The Draw | by Michael

No running play has epitomized the finesse-oriented ground game of 2005 and 2006 like the draw play. Designed to look like a pass is imminent, the draw is a way to fool opposing defenses rather than to impose one's will through merciless and constant hammering in the trenches. And during last August, when Charlie Weis uttered the infamous phrase from which this series of posts derives its name, how many fans truly believed that the draw, the ideal complement to a passing offense, would play second fiddle?

Year % of All Runs YPC
2005 26% 5.3
2006 30% 4.6
2008 22% 4.9

It actually happened. Last year Charlie Weis and Mike Haywood abandoned the draw play as the centerpiece of the rushing offense in favor of trying to pound the ball more, even if the overall attempt was an inconsistent and unsuccessful ground attack. As the table above illustrates, draw plays were down from the offense's banner years of '05 and '06. In fact, the very series of runs that finished at the top of the playcall sheet for both those years fell to just third place, ahead of only the Toss and the Jab.

In this attempt to break down the draw plays in the Irish offense, we will categorize draws into three types: one back draw plays with the quarterback under center; two back draw plays with the quarterback under center; and last, shotgun draw plays.

H 40/41
This is a one back draw that is typically run with three wide receivers. (Another type of draw, H44/45 is similar but utilizes two tight ends. It was rarely seen last year for obvious reasons.) It seems pretty straightforward, although from time to time, if a lineman is uncovered, he will pull around like in the diagram to the right. Most of these runs have been called to the right side, and draws to the left are marked by a distinct pivot by the quarterback before delivering the hand-off. In the clips below, which highlight the longest runs from 2005 and 2006, one can't help but notice how many times the interior blocking breaks down and Darius Walker is forced to bounce it outside. Who made these plays successful, the offensive line or Walker?



In quite a few of those clips, especially when the defense wasn't blitzing, Brady Quinn's initial dropback froze the linebackers and gave linemen just enough time to get to the second level to make their block. At the same time, it's easy to see why this was a run that catered to Walker's vision. He got the ball deep in the hole, the linebackers were typically further away from the line of scrimmage, and he had a choice of holes to choose from. Further, as you can see from the table below, when Walker's more experienced offensive linemen like Mark Levoir and Dan Stevenson moved on, the play was less successful, although dropping to a 5.2 yards per play average isn't terribly worrisome.

Year Attempts YPC
2005 30 6.2
2006 41 5.2
2008 22 4.4

Last year saw the fewest rushing attempts and the worst average. And after watching the following clips, its drop-off in production and usage seems understandable. The backs in these clips rarely get a clean shot through a hole, and if they do have an opening, the linemen appear to be flailing around the second level, hopelessly trying to sustain blocks on linebackers.



Robert Hughes ran that play eight times and picked up a measly ten yards all of last year. Most of his carries looked like the plays in that clip. But by contrast, check out Armando Allen below. Allen toted the ball 12 times, producing 80 yards with a 6.7 yards per carry average and a median carry of 5 yards. Secondly, compare Hawaii's defensive fronts in the clips above to those seen below. Far more advantageous when linebackers are deeper and not aligned on the line of scrimmage.




H 42/43 Ace
The next Irish draw play incorporates two backs, with the fullback leading the halfback through a hole. An example can be seen in the diagram to the right. Another common version of this play - seen in 2005 and 2006 - had the tight end motion into the backfield as a fullback. You might recall that Joseph Fauria did this a few times in the spring game with much success. And as you watch the clips from several years ago, notice how rarely on these highlights that Walker is forced to bounce the run outside because of shoddy blocking. Whereas quite a few of the H 40/41 plays were successful because of Walker bouncing them and outrunning the defense to the sideline, here the offensive line blocking is more responsible for success on these runs.



Somewhat surprisingly, this draw play was actually more successful in 2008 than in previous years. Looking back, Walker always seemed to run better without a fullback, when he was free to pick and choose his holes rather than follow a blocker, so that could explain the modest average in 2005. The dip below four yards per carry in 2006 was probably at least partially attributable to Asaph Schwapp's season-ending injury against Penn State. If there was one play where Schwapp seemed to excel, this was it.

Year Attempts YPC
2005 30 4.5
2006 30 3.8
2008 25 5.3

In terms of 2008, there is no better way to describe the Irish improvement than to simply show some clips. The ones below, taken from the same two games as the earlier clips, and with the same halfback who averaged 1.3 yards per carry on the other draw play, make the Irish look like an entirely different team. Watch all the linemen and Dan Wenger, in particular.


By the way, amazing read and tackle by the Hawaii defensive end on that first draw. If he doesn't make that play, Hughes would have picked up 15+ yards easily. But getting back to the point, the Irish offensive line certainly seemed more comfortable running these plays, especially Wenger, who effortlessly moved off combo blocks to seal off middle linebackers.

Shotgun Draws
The last set of draws to examine are the plays from shotgun formations, which I've decided to group together even if they are designed to hit different holes (or could even be labeled as H 40/41). Despite the diminished role of the draw in the overall Irish offense, one cannot help but notice the dramatic jump in draw plays from shotgun formations in 2008.

Year Attempts YPC
2005 5 5.8
2006 10 3.8
2008 21 5.1

In all but three games, the Irish ran no more than one draw play from shotgun formations. Against Pitt, it appeared as though the Irish saw something in film study, as they opened with a specific shotgun formation and draw play not seen that much all year. They ran that play six times in the first quarter alone and picked up 41 yards. Two other times they called it as well. Against Boston College, they ran four, and those were the result of an inefficient offense stuck in third and long situations. Ditto the two at Michigan State.



As the data clearly demonstrates, the Irish running game began to shed its over-reliance on the draw play last year. Unfortunately, the on-field results were so unsatisfactory that this positive is easily overlooked. What about 2009? A few predictions...
  • The use of H 42/43 Ace will be wholly dependent upon the staff's ability to develop a fullback. No competent fullback will likely mean more draws with three receivers (H 40/41) or two tight ends (H 44/45). For the sake of diversifying the offense and making it less predictable, somebody needs to emerge at fullback.
  • Draw play usage, as a percentage of the offense, will increase. It's just impossible to see a scenario where teams can afford to put seven in the box against the Irish passing attack. ND will face many six man fronts as a result. Weis will then take what the defense gives him and call more runs, including draws.
  • Armando Allen will remind fans of Darius Walker, and what he lacks in vision he makes up for in speed and lack of fear. He's not afraid to lower a shoulder into a defender rather than make an additional cut to avoid the contact.
If the Irish win, and if the overall ground game improves, few will care that the draw play is a bigger facet of the offense. But if the draw is one of the only running plays that consistently works, history may repeat itself come January 2010. And that's just not good enough.

Friday, July 24, 2009

Here Come the Irish 2009 | by Pat

The latest issue of Here Come the Irish has hit the newstands and Maple Street Press decided to once again let BGS chip in. Writers from NDNation, UHND, Classic Ground, Dr. Saturday, Football Outsiders, the Dean of Local Sports, Jeff Jeffers himself, and many more also have contributed to this year's version of the most in-depth pre-season annual you'll find.

Many of you have picked up the Annual in previous years so I'll skip the hard sell and just direct you to the Maple Street Press site, where you can find a full table of contents and the all-important order information.

Apropos of the recent posts here about scheduling, I thought I'd excerpt Brian Fremeau's excellent article about ND's scheduling: past, present, and future. For those who don't know, Brian is an ND grad and writer for Football Outsiders, one of the best number-crunching football sites out there. Here's a brief glimpse of Brian writing about ND's strength of schedule using his own methodology and hints that the strength of schedule for 2009 might not be as bad as some might think.

The trends in Table 4 are more plainly apparent. Notre Dame hasn’t played a particularly top-loaded slate since the early ’90s. 2009 marks the third year out of the last four in which only two teams with at least a Very Good APP rating appear on the schedule. Only three teams from the Elite-21 power list in Table 2 will play ND in 2009, and two of them, Michigan and Washington, are experiencing program rating nadirs themselves. Is this a crisis?

One thing to consider before answering that question definitively is the overall decline in scheduling philosophy on a national scale over the last decade or so. In 1997, only 38 games between FBS and FCS games were played, equivalent to 5.9% of scheduled non-bowl games among major college football teams. In 2008, 87 FBS vs. FCS games were played (11.3% of scheduled games). Appalachian State didn’t exactly usher in an era of parity when it defeated Michigan in 2007, either. FBS vs. FCS games are almost always slam dunks, and have been that way forever. Since 2003, FBS teams with only two wins or fewer to their name are still 51-10 against FCS competition. When more and more programs are electing to grab an “automatic” victory, is Notre Dame appropriately following suit by playing fewer “heavyweights”?

Consider also that the 2009 schedule, as weak as it is projected to be, still rates as stronger than 20 of the 25 schedules played by No. 1 programs since 1985. That includes each of the last five seasons in which USC has held the mantle. Part of the reason for that, of course, is that in the head-to-head match-up, Notre Dame gets credit for facing an Elite opponent in the Trojans, whereas USC only gets credit for playing an Above Average opponent in the Irish. Still, if USC had played a program of its own APP caliber in place of Notre Dame since 2005, its SOS ratings would fall to around 0.12, similar to ND’s ratings over the same time period.
It's articles like that, along with an expanded roster preview section and plenty of great insight from some passionate ND fans that will help fill up these next few weeks separating us from the greatest time of the year: college football season.

Thursday, July 23, 2009

Short-lived stir-up? | by Pat

Only days after the TCU rumor surfaced, it sounds like it is getting batted down.

TCU likely won't add Notre Dame to its 2010 schedule, according to a source familiar with the situation.

Despite reports that Notre Dame was looking to add both TCU and Tulsa to its 2010 slate, TCU's schedule is already booked and probably won't change.
The brief article does float the possibility of ND playing TCU in 2011 or 2012, but it sure sounds like ND still has one game to fill on the 2010 schedule assuming the Tulsa game is a go. TCU did confirm talking with ND about a potential game, but didn't make it sound like too much progress was made.
A TCU release stated: "We’ve had dialogue with Notre Dame just like we’ve had with many other schools regarding a possible future game."
With Swarbrick mentioning that he would like to have the 2010 schedule finalized before the start of the 2009 season, more concrete reports about the final 2010 opponent should hit the wire in the next month or so.

Bronx Bound | by Pat

Notre Dame will be returning to the Bronx and subway alumni will once again be able to live up to their moniker. After rumor and speculation earlier in the year, a 2010 game against Army in the new New York Yankees Stadium was made official on Monday at a press conference in New York. The game is set for November 20th, 2010, ND's second to last game of the season. (Hopefully the ground crew won't leave dugout-shaped holes in the endzone.)

ND has played Army 22 of the 24 times it played in the old Yankees Stadium. Notable matchups included the famous "Win One for the Gipper" game in 1928, as well as the 0-0 tie in 1946 which featured three eventual Heisman Tropy winners. The series may not be so competitive lately, but for fans of tradition, the choice of opponent given this famous venue is an easy one.

"Any student of Notre Dame football history knows the meaning of the Notre Dame-Army rivalry and, in particular, the history of that rivalry at Yankee Stadium," said Notre Dame athletics director Jack Swarbrick. "It's fitting that a Notre Dame-Army game will be the first football event in this fabulous facility -- and it's also fitting that the 50th meeting in this great rivalry will take place in a venue with such great tradition for both programs."
The announcement was a whole-day affair, with Army coach Rich Ellerson and Charlie, Jr. throwing out the first pitch at that afternoon's home game. As the picture in the upper right shows, Ellerson and Weis got commemorative Yankees jerseys, a gesture that echoes Babe Ruth putting on an ND jersey some 82 years ago. In addition, more games in Yankee Stadium for future seasons were announced. Assuming the first handful go off well, it wouldn't be a surprise to see ND return to New York in the future for more games at the new Yankees Stadium.

While on the topic of 2010 games, more rumors started to swirl about the last two open slots on the 2010 schedule. With not much time left and many teams already done filling out their dance cards, the latest internet scuttlebutt has ND lining up games against Texas Christian and Tulsa.

So far, the only official comments have been about the Tulsa game, which seems like it's basically a done deal at this point.
As reported Monday on tulsaworld.com , TU is close to finalizing a deal with Notre Dame for an Oct. 30 game at South Bend, Ind.

"The two universities are in discussions to play football in the 2010 season," said Don Tomkalski, TU associate athletic director for communications. "No contract has been signed."
Assuming that the Golden Hurricane takes the pre-Halloween spot, that leaves October 16th and November 6th still open for the Irish. TCU might take one of those spots, preferably for ND the latter (colder and gives ND the bye week in the middle of the season).

Up front, I'll say that nothing is wrong with ND playing TCU or Tulsa. Both teams were in the Top 25 at some point last season, with TCU finishing the year in the Top 10.
TCU had the #1 defense in the country last year and Tulsa has had the #1 offense in the country the last two seasons. They certainly aren't as bad as a handful of BCS conference teams. As a bit of trivia, Tulsa is the hometown of some familiar-sounding ND donor families like LaFortune, Warren, and Seigfried. And TCU is a private, religious institution, similar to BYU and Baylor. I have no problem with ND playing games against such universities now and again.

But when looked at in context with the rest of ND's 2010 schedule, the combination of these games leave much to be desired from ND schedule-wise. Look at the second half of the season, leading up to the November 27th season finale at Southern Cal.
Oct. 23rd - Navy (in Meadowlands)
Oct. 30th - Tulsa
Nov. 6th - TCU (tba)
Nov. 13th - Utah
Nov. 20th - Army (in Yankee Stadium)
That's five straight games against non-BCS conference teams. True, TCU and Utah finished the 2008 season in the Top 10 and could very well be highly ranked when they travel to South Bend. But let's look at the bigger picture.

The 2010 home game slate would feature Purdue, Michigan, Stanford, Pittsburgh, Tulsa, Utah, and possibily TCU. For Notre Dame fans, that's not too appetizing. To be clear, this isn't so much of looking down our nose at a Tulsa or TCU as much as wondering where all big name (home) games are. Like nearly every single ND fan, I don't want 12 straight games against the elites of the gridiron, but if you threw in a Texas or Wisconsin or Georgia alongside the Tulsas and TCUs then the whole picture changes. There are still the rumors that ND is trying to line up more name opponents, but until one is officially scheduled, it's fair to question if and when it will happen as long as ND continues to try and make the 7-4-1 schedule model work.

Tuesday, July 21, 2009

Friday the 13th | by Pat

For the second time this summer, a cornerback from Florida made the trip to South Bend to announce his public commitment to Notre Dame. This time it was Cape Coral native Spencer Boyd who on Friday announced his intentions to become the 13th member of the 2010 recruiting class.

“The people and the coaching staff definitely think I can compete and play early,” said Boyd, a 5-foot-10, 178-pound defensive back, who chose the Fighting Irish over Michigan and Georgia. “No matter what happens, having a degree from Notre Dame will make me successful.”
You can see a brief clip of his announcement here.

Boyd follows a similar script as other ND recruits this year; he's a three star recruit with some quality offers. Both Rivals and Scout list Boyd as a 3-star guy. Rivals has him as the #26 overall corner and Scout has him as the #28 corner. His 79 grade on ESPN puts him in the middle of the recruiting class pack. Finalists Michigan and Georgia, as well as Miami, North Carolina, Ole Miss, Duke, and Stanford all tried to woo Boyd but fell short

Youtube has highlights of his injury-shortened junior year as well as some clips of him playing running back his sophomore year. Showing off his running back skills and continuing the trend in this year's recruiting class, Boyd won MVP honors at a National Underclassmen Combine in Miami, Florida in 2oo8.

Like Lo Wood and possibly Chris Badger, Boyd is planning on enrolling early, meaning all three curent DB recruits could be on campus for spring practice in 2010. Speaking of 2010, here's the 2010 cornerback position depth chart. Wood and Boyd solidify the corner position with ND looking to perhaps land one more in this class.


Fifth Year
Senior Junior Sophomore Freshman
Darrin Walls
Gary Gray*
Robert Blanton
E.J. Banks
Lo Wood


J. Slaughter *

Spencer Boyd


Now that there are 13 recruits in this class, perhaps it's time to look at the overall numbers. This table will include all 5th year players eligible (Ryan Burkhart, Barry Gallup, Leonard Gordon, Paddy Mullen, Chris Stewart, Kallen Wade, Darrin Walls, and Dan Wenger) even though not all of them will likely wind up back on campus.

Fifth Year
Senior Junior Sophomore Freshman
8
17
22
18
13

With 78 scholarships accounted for and the limit still set at 85, that leaves 7 more available scholarships in this recruiting class for a grand total of 20. When additional attrition inevitably strikes, be it injury, ResLife, or transfer, there will be room for a few more. Odds are, by the time Signing Day rolls around, ND will have room for 23-25 players in the 2010 recruiting class, giving ND around 10-12 more open slots. With Boyd looking to join a few classmates in early enrollment, then he would technically count towards last year's class and ND could go over the 25-man limit in this class should there be a hefty amount of attrition. Either way, look for ND to have room for at least 10 more recruits in the 2010 recruiting class.

Sunday, July 19, 2009

Impound It - The Jab | by Michael

After taking on the Toss Play in the first installment of "Impound It," we now turn our attention to the set of misdirection plays known as the Jab series. This family of runs shares the distinctive ball-handling of the quarterback. He opens to one direction with the ball extended, then turns quickly and hands the ball off to the tailback heading in the opposite direction. Similarly, the tailback takes a step in one direction, then quickly cuts back to receive the hand-off. Jab runs were called 41 times (13.3%) by the Irish in 2008, and we'll take a look at two of them below. However, one note of caution before we proceed. These running plays, as well as the ones to be analyzed in future posts, can be harder to classify because of nuances in blocking schemes. Possessing only a partial Patriots/Notre Dame playbook leaves chance for error.


Jab 32/33 Bend
This play, seen to the right, is a weakside counter play. The halfback reads from inside out, meaning he starts with the first covered lineman to the playside. The fullback's responsibility is to block the last man on the line of scrimmage. Linemen just fire out and hit the guy in front of them-- this is not a zone blocking scheme.

Jab 32/33 Bend appears to have been used most in 2005, when it was called 28 times. It averaged 7.0 yards to the left and 5.6 to the right; the Irish ran it left just about two-thirds of the time. It was also spread out amongst three different personnel groupings: Regular (HB, FB, TE, WR, WR); Detroit (HB, TE, TE, WR, WR), and Two Tites (HB, FB, TE, TE, WR). In addition, it was a very common play at the end of games when the Irish wanted to wear down an opponent. The following year, it was used about half as often, just 15 times. Knee injuries to Asaph Schwapp and John Carlson likely contributed to that decline in use. Again the run worked extremely well to the left, averaging over 8 yards per carry to the left, and again it was run to that side two-thirds of the time. When run right, the graduation of Mark Levoir and Dan Stevenson were likely reasons for the average dropping below 4 yards per carry.



In 2008, this run was seen primarily with Regular personnel, although it was also utilized with a second tight end early in the season. When Will Yeatman was suspended, that incarnation of the play disappeared from the call sheet. Like in previous years, it was also a common play for the back-ups (Jonas Gray, Steve Paskorz, et al.) to run in garbage time as the Irish tried to run out the clock.

Personnel
Grouping
Rushes Yards
Per Carry
Median Yards
Per Carry
Detroit 9 4.6
4
Regular 17 3.6 3
(Garbage Time)
8 3.0
1.5

Performance in Regular looks mediocre until one breaks down the individual carries, where it becomes clear that Aldridge ran the ball with authority while Hughes struggled.

Player
Rushes Yards
Per Carry
Median Yards
Per Carry
Aldridge 12 4.8
3.5
Hughes 7 1.7 1

Yet before one entirely dismisses Hughes for those woeful stats, keep in mind that all of the Detroit carries are his. Perhaps he works better alone than with a fullback in front of him, although these two runs against Stanford from 2007 suggest otherwise. Notice this third run is the same play but with Yeatman replacing Schwapp.

Jab 36/37
Two primary differences exist between Jab 32/33 Bend and this run. First, it's always run to the strongside of the formation. Next, as you can see from the diagram to the right, the backside guard pulls and takes on a linebacker. It's almost exclusively run from formations with three wide receivers, which places a lot of pressure on a defense because if they cheat a linebacker or defensive back into the box to support the run, that opens up the passing game. On the other hand, choosing to keep just six men in the box obviously makes running the ball that much easier. Every now and then it'll be run with two tight ends, although to be honest, those seem to be against smaller, outmatched fronts like Navy's.

The best examples of this play from 2005 and 2006 can be seen below. I'd recommend watching it twice, once to watch the offense, and a second time to watch the linebackers. The play is most effective when linebackers bite on that initial quarterback movement because that gives the linemen an extra moment to get to the second level and seal them off. (USC's linebackers are probably the worst in this regard.)



In terms of playcalling history, the Irish dialed up this run 16 times in 2005 and averaged 4.4 yards per carry. Only twice was it run to the left, so it's quite likely that pulling was not one of right guard Dan Stevenson's strengths. Then again, Stevenson pulled on other plays, like tosses, so there might be something unique with this play that caused it to be run almost exclusively behind Dan Santucci. Also of note is that Darius Walker was tackled in the backfield on one out of every five carries. The following year its use doubled. Because the more athletic Santucci became a full-time starter, the Irish called it 20 times to the right and 10 times to the left (behind Bob Morton's pull). Results were outstanding as it averaged 6.3 yards per carry to the right and 8.0 yards per carry to the left. Not once in 2006 was it stopped behind the line of scrimmage, and only once was it stuffed for no gain.

Last year, Jab 36/37 was called just six times, but four of those runs picked up ten yards or more. In fact, it averaged 9.7 yards per carry, and the median carry was 12 yards. Twice it was called against North Carolina, once against Pitt in overtime, and then three times in the bowl game. All six plays are below.


So why wasn't it called more often? Your guess is as good as mine, but it's hard to fathom that the staff didn't have a legitimate reason. Although some might point to our guards' athleticism and talent at pulling, it is also worth noting that, according to the playbook, there are more offensive line calls to make depending upon the defensive front that is faced. In other words, it seems to require more communication than other runs. That could explain why the bulk of these carries occurred in the bowl game, when the Irish could have spent more time practicing it.



Looking at the series as a whole, the two Jab runs averaged 4.5 yards per carry this year, a pretty solid stat until you consider that it averaged 5.4 yards per carry in 2005 and 5.6 the following year. Further reflection yields the following questions:
  • Will the other strongside counter, Jab 32/33, return to gameplans? That run showed up twice, against Michigan and Stanford, and then took a sabbatical for the rest of 2008. It was a much bigger part of the Irish offense in 2005 and 2006. Along those lines,will the addition of another running play make the Irish offense more efficient and less predictable?
  • Similarly, will the return of Mike Ragone allow for the Irish to become more varied and less predictable in who-- and how-- they line up to run these plays?
  • Who is going to play fullback, and if it's Aldridge, will the Irish still run Jab 32/33 Bend? Can the tailback/fullback hybrid block a defensive end, and if not, will personnel substitutions make playcalling more predictable?
  • Will Jab 36/37 find its way into more games than just the three of 2008?
The Jab series has important implications in terms of the overall ground game. At the same time, it's also proven to be one of the most dangerous play action passes in the arsenal. (Here's a tease.) But play action is meaningless if the ground game doesn't earn the defense's respect. As the questions outlined above clearly suggest, the entire Irish offensive coaching staff, not just Frank Verducci, has their work cut out for them.

Friday, July 17, 2009

More Pistol | by Kevin

Chris Brown of Smart Football has penned an illuminating overview of Nevada's "Pistol" formation, with video and analysis that should provide a helpful addition or supplement to our earlier overview of the Irish's first 2009 opponent.

My take on the Pistol in general, as well as the veer explained in detail at the end of Smart Football's writeup, remains the same: crash it. Stay in your lanes, remember your keys, but move -- make them pay for that split second lost on the fake handoff. ND should have one of the ten-best secondaries in the country this year. Until proven otherwise, trust the back three or four to stop Nevada's relatively inefficient (54% completion rate in 2008) passing game, then use ND's presumably superior front seven/eight athletes to pressure and neutralize Kaepernick's rushing game.

Wednesday, July 15, 2009

Jake in Progress | by Kevin

Note on the title of this entry: I sifted through countless Nirvana and Pearl Jam references for a groan-inducing title to the Washington preview. Found Dead In the Greenhouse, while evocative, seemed in poor taste. Young Former USC Coach Behind the Counter in a Big Town was too long and detached from the original Pearl Jam track. A Google search for "TV shows about Jake" produced the eventual winner. John Stamos played Jake, and the show was eventually pulled in favor of Bachelor re-runs. While new coach Steve Sarkisian may eventually lead a Trista-and-Ryan charmed life in Seattle, roses are not in the program's immediate future.


Steve Sarkisian, like his former USC co-offensive coordinator Lane Kiffin, has imported some Trojan coaching staples to Seattle. Sark has brought in a top-flight former USC defensive coach (Nick Holt), turned the Twitter volume to 11, and generally injected the Husky program with Carroll-esque optimism and energy.

However, Coach Sarkisian was not able to load all of Heritage Hall into the moving van. Traveler didn't make the trip. Neither did Keith Rivers, Matt Leinart, Carson Palmer, Dwayne Jarrett, Steve Smith, Mike Williams, Rey Maualuga, Brian Cushing, Dominique Bird, Winston Justice, Ryan Kalil, Sam Baker, Reggie Bush, LenDale White, Mark Sanchez, Jeff Byers, Stanley Havili, Taylor Mays, Joe McKnight, Everson Griffen, or Ronald Johnson.

In short, Sarkisian has gone from a program that has "settled" for throttling Big Ten teams in the Rose Bowl every January 1st to one whose former coach was proud to play Hawaii in December. In a regular season game. That they lost.

The cupboard is not entirely empty. Lest anyone forget, Jake Locker returns at quarterback. The obligatory Jake Locker compliments feel similar to telling someone from a bottom-tier academic school that they "have a great nursing program." While true -- Locker is a talented athlete and a seemingly likeable kid -- the point feels a bit empty and condescending given the context.

The context is this: Washington has been terrible. Washington might become excellent during the Sarkisian Era. With access to junior college players, they could be good reasonably soon. But they will not be good this year. I do not think Notre Dame should or will lose a home game against this team.

With the conclusion out of the way early, let's take a closer look at the 2009 Washington Huskies.

The team starts with the nursing program. Locker, the dual-threat Bellingham, Washington native, was Willingham's recruiting pearl, albeit one who dreamed of Montlake since childhood. Locker has been star-crossed since arriving at Washington. His 1,000-yard rushing campaign as a redshirt freshman was cut a game short, with an injury against Oregon State, and he missed most of last season after breaking his thumb in the fourth game, against Stanford. He has also played for a team that has won nine games in three seasons. Still, if Sarkisian's pro-style system and Locker mesh, and/or Sarkisian adapts to the speedy quarterback, Locker might finally emerge and enjoy his finest year.

The other blue-chippers on offense are redshirt freshman running back Chris Polk (also injured last year) and two tight ends, sophomores Kavario Middleton and Chris Izbicki. Polk was Scout.com's 9th-rated running back in the class of 2008, with offers from USC, Cal, and Oregon, and he should be the nominal starter heading into the fall. However, he will likely share carries with some or all of Demetrius Bronson, Willie Griffin, Brandon Johnson, and/or David Freeman. Middleton and Izbicki should split time. At wide receiver, D'Andre Goodwin returns from a 721-yard campaign. Jermaine Kearse, a former four-star recruit who saw limited playing time as a true freshman, should also start. Devin Aguilar, who also played as a true freshman, Cody Bruns, Vince Taylor, and Anthony Boyle round out the receivers.

Washington's 2008 offensive line was even worse than Notre Dame's. Washington averaged just under 100 rushing yards per game last year and yielded 31 sacks. The good news for Husky fans is that two starters graduated. Some attention has focused on the big guys' weight. Though right guard Senio Kelemete and right tackle Drew Schaefer both weigh in at less than 280, the rest of the group -- particularly 335 pound left guard Ben Ossai -- is anything but svelte. Perhaps they just need assistance re-distributing that weight. Learning how to block could also come in handy.

Defense should be the way the Huskies first announce their return. New coordinator Nick Holt led the already legendary USC defense last year, and no reasonable observer questions the value he brings to the Washington staff. Every 2008 starting defensive lineman and linebacker returns. Top tacklers Mason Foster (outside linebacker), Daniel Te'o-Nesheim (defensive end), and Donald Butler (inside linebacker) are back, as is outside linebacker EJ Savannah, who had left the team before last season. Sophomore Quinton Richardson returns at corner, along with Matt Mosley and Justin Glenn, and safeties Nate Williams, Johri Fogerson, and Greg Walker.

Special teams could doom the Huskies in any close games. Neither their kicker nor punter have played Division I football. Punter Will Mahan is a Juco transfer, while kicker Eric Folk did not play in his first two seasons at Washington. Their return game is also unsettled, although Polk could become involved in that capacity.

After an 11-37 run under Tyrone Willingham -- which featured, among other ignominies, the retention of just 17 total players from the combined 2005 and 2006 recruiting classes -- at least Washington fans finally have hope. Wins may not come early. Washington opens against LSU, and USC visits on September 19th. If Sarkisian can keep morale intact, his experienced defense might pull off a surprise at some point this season. Just not on October 3rd.

Tuesday, July 14, 2009

Add One Moore To The List | by Pat

Chalk up another recruit. ND is up to 12 in the current recruiting class with the latest announcement. North Carolina linebacker Kendall Moore picked ND as his school of choice at a presser this past weekend.

"It's just a whole bunch of things, a combination of things," said Moore about why he chose Notre Dame. "Academically and athletically it was the best choice for me."
Moore liked ND enough during his unofficial visit this summer that he committed to the staff before leaving, making the public announcement on Saturday. He's the first linebacker recruit in this class and gives the current tally an even split of six offensive recruits and six defensive recruits.

Rivals put the 6'3" 232 pound Moore in the 4-star category and the 167th overall recruit. He's also their 14th ranked outside linebacker. Scout thinks his future lies on the inside as they have him as a 3-star guy and the 17th ranked middle linebacker. ESPN handed out a 77 ranking and says he could potentially play either inside or outside. His offers included Florida State, North Carolina, NC State, South Carolina, Clemson, and others. Credit Corwin Brown for pulling Moore out of ACC/SEC territory.

Highlights-wise, ESPN has free clips of Moore last season while Rivals has some up-close shots of Moore from a combine earlier in the spring. From first glance, Moore looks quick enough to play on the outside, but if he keeps growing and adding weight, he might wind up a middle linebacker candidate.

Something to keep an eye on though, Moore used his commitment presser to also mention he was still sorta, kinda looking around.
"Yes sir, definitely," Moore told Irish Illustrated. "I felt like this is the start of my decision. I'm still going to wait throughout the whole season and see what goes on. I haven't talked to coach Weis about it, but I think that's pretty much accurate."
On the one hand, let's wait until Moore has that chat with Charlie first. On the other hand, Moore is merely doing what many top recruits are going to do this season. They want to see first-hand how the ND team looks before jumping on board. Moore liked ND enough during his visit to pull the trigger, but it can't be too comforting that he's already giving himself an out. Still, until he starts taking visits, it's probably still safe to keep him in the "commit" pile. (It's also a safe assumption that ND is looking for other possible LB candidates.)

Here's the chart for all of the linebackers. Granted it might be a bit more precise if this was broken down into inside versus outside guys, but with Moore's ultimate position a bit up in the air, not to mention the same dilemma for a number of younger linebackers on the squad, here is the 2010 list for the entire linebacking position.

Fifth Year
Senior Junior Sophomore Freshman

Brian Smith
Darius Fleming
Manti Te'o
Kendall Moore


Steve Filer
Carlo Calabrese



Anthony McDonald*
Zeke Motta



David Posluszny*
Dan Fox


Some exciting names on there that could form a potentially stellar linebacking corp in 2010. There is also a noticeably big cluster of players in the junior and sophomore classes, which was needed given the lack of LBs in the 5th year and senior classes. It's possible that Te'o could be on a mission in 2010 and Zeke Motta might be listed with the safeties, so keep that in mind when taking the above table and mentally constructing a two-deep. Still, while Moore might be physically ready to play when he shows up, but his first crack at playing time might be on special teams given the returning list of players.

Monday, July 13, 2009

Impound It - The Toss Play | by Michael

Pop Quiz: What's the longest rushing touchdown by a tailback in the Weis era? (Answer below.)

That piece of trivia nagged me after a few observant readers commented on the conspicuous absence of the running game from last week's 2008 top ten list. Likewise, a quick scan of the new Top Plays of the Weis Era poll on UND.com reveals only one tailback run out of thirty plays, and that play is likely included more for its significance (Irish sealing a BCS berth in 2005) than anything else. Even in 2007, the worst rushing offense in Notre Dame history ironically produced two memorable runs by James Aldridge and Robert Hughes that would have likely made this list. Also consider: Hughes's 45-yard rush would have tied Kevin Faulk for longest run by a Patriot back during Weis's tenure there, and Aldridge's 43-yard scamper would have placed him third. Breakaway touchdown runs have been scarce on recent Weis-coached teams.

But back to the Irish. After a little research, the longest rush by a back last year was a rather embarrassing 21 yards, achieved three separate times by Armando Allen against Purdue. Sadly, no one else in the Irish backfield broke the 20 yard plateau for the rest of the season. Fast-forward a couple months, and Frank Verducci is coaching the offensive line with Tony Alford handling the backs. Fast-forward a couple more months, and there are obligatory "the running game is improving" comments from spring football. Keep fast-forwarding, and there are hints from local beat writers that one offensive line starter is moving to center to replace a weak link in last year's line and make room for a rapidly improving youngster. It all sounds so perfect, right?

Back the truck up. Let's take one last look at 2008, one running play concept at a time, in ascending order of usage.


The Toss Play

Diagrammed to the right, the running play utilized the least last year was also the worst. The toss play averaged an abysmal 1.32 (that's no typo) yards per carry on only 19 carries. The Irish ran it to the weakside and to the strongside, and when run to the weakside, it always employed a fullback as a lead blocker. The toss play wasn't always so horrendous. In 2005, the toss play was called 51 times and averaged 4.57 yards per carry. In 2006, those numbers dipped to 34 carries and 3.08 yards per carry, still twice as productive as the '08 version.

The toss play owns the dubious distinction of losing the most yards on a single carry, as the Irish lost seven yards on two separate occasions against both Hawaii and Boston College. Worse yet, the starting offense ran it to the strongside left six times all year, and only once did it result in positive yardage. For the season, the strongside left toss averaged -0.86 yards per carry, and that's with a ten-yard gain by Jonas Gray in garbage time against Washington. Below are two familiar examples from games against Southern Cal and Hawaii.



Feel free to analyze those plays in the comments section, but here are some quick thoughts. One, Kyle Rudolph's lack of strength is obvious. I can't speak to blocking fundamentals, but it's doubtful that spring football caused a regression in either. He had nowhere to go but up. Second, there's usually one player who causes bad things to happen. In the first play, it's Stewart. He can't block the weakside tackle, who makes the play in the hole. Maybe the play had a chance otherwise. In the second, it's Rudolph. When he gets pushed back, it forces Schwapp wider, which forces Hughes wider, which allows the linebackers to run away from the linemen trying to block them. It looks like Eric Olsen makes a poor attempt at a block, but the reality is, if Rudolph isn't pushed back, forcing the entire play wider, that linebacker would be within his grasp.

There is little doubt that an improved offensive line and a stronger Rudolph should result in improved production and greater usage. Another item to watch closely is whether Aldridge's speed is utilized as a lead blocker. When the play was successful in 2005 and early 2006, some of the most successful toss plays were with the more athletic Rashon Powers-Neal at fullback or John Carlson as a move TE or h-back.



That clip from the 2005 Washington game was one of five toss plays that picked up 13 yards or more. Powers-Neal was a lead blocker on four of them. When he played, the toss play averaged 4.9 yards per carry with a median carry of 6 yards. By contrast, although the toss play averaged 4.8 yards per carry with Schwapp, the median carry was only 3 yards. If Aldridge welcomes the blocking assignments of playing fullback, his speed should be an asset. If not, it's up to Steve Paskorz or one of the tight ends.

Lastly, the offensive line must play more consistently. The play of the backs and tight ends is important, but everything begins up front. Watching Ryan Harris in those clips reminds one that Notre Dame hasn't had that kind of dominating offensive line play since he left. Ditto Mark Levoir. It was nice to see Trevor Robinson land on top of his man in the first set of clips, just as it was great to see Mike Turkovich stone his defender in both. The Irish offense is going to need more of that kind of line play in 2009.

Next up: The Jab Counter

Trivia answer here. As far as 2008, the longest score by a back was a boring, straight-ahead 16-yard rush by Allen against Purdue. No broken tackles, no jukes, not even a stiff-arm. Allen was in the endzone before a lineman could even pancake his opponent.

Saturday, July 11, 2009

Pieces of Steele | by Jay

Phil Steele always appends his jam-packed preview guide with a few pages of feature articles concerning various football metrics. This year is no exception. I thought I'd highlight two of his metrics and see what they say about the Irish and their opponents this year. Both of these metrics try to predict improvement (or regression) based on some simple counting items.

"For Better or Worse: Close Wins, Close Losses." This metric posits that a team that suffers a lot of close losses (defined by Steele as a touchdown or less) will probably improve the following year; likewise, a team that benefits from a lot of close wins stands to regress.

Steele runs the numbers for the past seven years and finds that teams that net more than 2 close losses improve their record 68% of the time the following year. On the flip side, a team that nets 2 or more close wins will see their record worsen 64% of the time; with three or more net close wins, that number climbs to 71%.

The Irish had 2 close wins (Stanford, Navy) and 3 close losses (North Carolina, Pittsburgh and Syracuse) for a net of -1, so the indicator probably doesn't indicate much for us. (Steele mentions that he sometimes throws out late scores that skew the results; perhaps you could treat the Navy game with its late touchdown in such a fashion, which would lower the ND score to net -2 and provide an indicator of improvement).

The other teams on the ND opponent slate look like this:

2009 Schedule
Close
Wins
Close
Losses
Net
Nevada (7-5) 1 3 -2
Michigan (3-9) 1 4 -3
Michigan State (9-3) 2 1 +1
Purdue (4-8) 2 2 0
Washington (0-12) 0 3 -3
Southern Cal (11-1) 1 1 0
Boston College (9-4) 4 2 +2
Washington St. (2-11) 1 0 +1
Navy (8-4) 4 1 +3
Pittsburgh (9-3) 4 1 +3
Connecticut (7-5) 3 2 +1
Stanford (5-7) 2 3 -1

So Nevada, Michigan and Washington would have a high chance to improve according to Steele, while Boston College, Navy and Pitt would stand to regress.

"Turnovers = Turnaround." Similar to the "Close Wins, Close Losses" metric is Steele's assessment of net turnovers as a predictor of improvement/regression the following year (drawing a line at net double-digit turnovers). In this study he looks over the past 16 years and finds 235 teams that had a net plus 10 turnovers or more. 154 of those then had weaker records the following year (65.5%). He also finds 191 teams minus 10 turnovers or worse, with 130 of them having better records the following year (68%). Again, these are pretty good indicators.

Turnovers Gained & Lost in 2008
2009 Schedule
Gained Lost
Net
Nevada (7-5) 25
24
+1
Michigan (3-9) 20
30
-10
Michigan State (9-3) 24
22
+2
Purdue (4-8) 20
23
-3
Washington (0-12) 10
27
-17
Southern Cal (11-1) 29
22
+7
Boston College (9-4) 36
33
+3
Washington St. (2-11) 13
38
-25
Navy (8-4) 30
15
+15
Pittsburgh (9-3) 24
27
-3
Connecticut (7-5) 25
29
-4
Stanford (5-7) 21
25
-4

Only four teams make Steele's net-10 cutoff: Michigan, Washington, and Washingston State all stand to improve, while Navy should expect a dropoff. Washington State, by the way, led the field in futility; their net -25 was the worst in college football last year.

For the Irish's part, they gained 25 turnovers but gave away 28, for a net loss of -3.

more 'brick | by Jay

Jack Swarbrick gave an interview to BGI the other day where he talked some more about scheduling concerns. In it, I was dismayed to hear Swarbrick trot out that old cliché about how N.D. fans, in their desire for more competitive schedules, want to face a "top 10 team every week." We heard this canard from White over the years while he was rationalizing a crummy slate of games; I heard it personally from Heisler at a seminar at N.D. This line really is a strawman: as Doug over at WeIsND points out, there are exactly zero folks clamoring for a murderer's row year-in, year-out.

I will allow that if you are the one answering the athletic department mail, it may seem that N.D. fans want lots and lots of big name teams; surely Swarbrick's office is getting a lot of letters imploring him to add Texas and Alabama and Georgia and so on. But there's a huge difference between wanting a couple of more "name" teams at the top, and something stupid like "top 10 teams every week." ND fans aren't stupid. Nobody wants 12 games in a row against top 10 teams. So it was disconcerting to hear Swarbrick prop up the same strawman. It makes us, the fans, sound like delusional masochists, which we aren't. (As Jack Lipnik would say, "Let's put a stop to THAT rumor right now!")

What folks do want is something much more reasonable and attainable: we want more diversity to the schedule, as befits a true independent, and we don't want to be locked into the same old teams year in, year out. And yes, we need to stay competitive, but not insanely so. Most of all, we'd like to make sure we have some interesting top-end names headlining each season -- not just Southern Cal and Michigan. That's about all the fans are looking for, Jack.



Despite the strawman utterance, there are, I think, important differences in what Swarbrick is saying about the schedule and what his wrongheaded predecessor wanted to do.

For one, Swarbrick simply isn't selling it like White did. In fact, it seems like he's leaving himself an out, just in case the whole 7-4-1 thing doesn't work:
The hardship Swarbrick faces is finding those teams who are willing to come to Notre Dame for game, without the benefit of a return visit from the Irish.

“Implementing it is very hard,” Swarbrick said. “Our fans would like to see us play a top-10 team every week. Well, top-10 teams aren’t going to come on a non home-and-home basis. Top 30 teams aren’t going to come on a non home-and-home basis. And so you have to balance those things…It’s much harder than I might have thought prior to sitting down and trying to fill in those blanks.”
I heard similar sentiments from Swarbrick relayed to me by a friend who heard him speak to an alumni group in Omaha recently; he talked about how "hard" it is to make it work. By repeatedly citing the hardships in executing the 7-4-1, I think he's setting up one of two possible outcomes: A) because it's impossible, we'll be getting zero bigger-name teams in the future, so prepare yourself for a lot of MAC and WAC and Sun Belt filler, or B) we're going to see some welcome backsliding on the rigidity of 7-4-1, cracking it open to include some more home-and-homes with the top 10/top 30 types.

This leads to my second point: given the profundity of on-the-record interviews Swarbrick has given on the topic, I don't think we should read the BGI piece in isolation. As we've documented here, there has been a lot of smoke concerning marquee matchups with Miami, Wisconsin, Texas, and the like emanating from Swarbrick's office recently. To our knowledge, none have been scheduled yet. But this chatter seems more in line with scenario B than scenario A, doesn't it? We shall see.

Friday, July 10, 2009

Rees is Missing Piece | by Pat

The phones in the Gug kept ringing this week as Illinois quarterback Tommy Rees made a quick decision after getting an offer from Notre Dame. Jumping at the chance, Rees committed to the Irish. He's the second QB to commit and the 11th overall member in the 2010 recruiting class.

‘‘I felt comfortable with [Notre Dame],’’ Rees said. ‘‘I like the coaches a lot. I’ll get a good education ... and the football tradition is something that’s important to me.’’
The recruiting sites for the most part haven't evaluated the 6'3" 195-pound Rees yet. He is still unranked on Rivals. Scout gave him 3 stars and slotted him as the 83rd-ranked QB in the class, but there is no indication that they have actually evaluated him, and it certainly looks that his ranking is merely a placeholder for now given the lack of highlight clips, bio, and the rest of the info usually found in a recruit's profile. ESPN didn't have a review of him up when he committed either, but they quickly rectified that and gave him a 78. They also issued a review that contains the same sleeper/upside buzzwords the last few recruits have elicited:
The first thing that jumps out about Rees is his release. In fact, we are surprised he has not received more attention due to his delivery alone at this stage. He is a prospect that coaches may look at and see an intriguing prospect three years down the road with upside and late bloomer potential.
ESPN also has the only highlight video of Rees I could find, so check him at the above link.

One of the reason Rees has been flying under the recruitnik radar was lack of attention from bigger programs. His initial set of offers included Central Michigan, Miami-Ohio, and Bowling Green. But then Stanford offered (granted, they "offer" anyone with a pulse these days) and so did Tennessee, apparently, after Rees went to a Vols football camp and was named QB MVP of the camp (granted, Kiffin gave out three QB MVP awards in the same camp). I say "apparently" offered because he's listed with a Tennessee offer on Rivals, but this UT article says the Vols were close to offering but never actually did.

How did the Irish get to know this unheralded prospect? ND had a chance to watch Rees work out and throw after he came to ND for this summer's football camp. After his showing, ND made the call to extend an offer.

Rees comes from a football family. His older brother is a punter at UCLA and his father has a long scouting and coaching history in both college and the NFL, last with the Browns. When asked to give a scouting review of his son, here is what he said.
''He could be an athletic pocket passer,'' Bill Rees said. ''He can move around and get out of trouble. He is a very accurate passer with arm ability. He can throw with touch and velocity and can throw deep. A college coach must ask: 'Does he fit into what we are doing?''
With two quarterbacks in this class, ND is definitely done recruiting the position for the year. After Clausen departs, Rees and Hendrix will battle it out to see who will back up Crist. In case Clausen goes pro after a strong 2009 season, ND will have three scholarship quarterbacks on the roster, even if two of them are freshmen. Taking two quarterbacks in this class is a good move to make up for the gap in last year's class and likely shouldn't have a big impact on next year's recruiting (just like it didn't during Clausen's recruitment after landing Jones and Frazer the year before).

Fifth Year
Senior Junior Sophomore Freshman

Jimmy Clausen
Dayne Crist*

Andrew Hendrix


Nate Montana*

Tommy Rees